Episode 37

Landrace Gardening with Joseph Lofthouse!

Published on: 3rd December, 2024

What is a land race? How is promiscuous pollination different from open pollinated? How do you maintain diversity over multiple seasons? Can a land race be scaled down successfully to flourish in a home garden? Does Joseph Lofthouse sing beautifully? All this and so much more in this episode of Song and Plants!

Opening tune: Solanaceae by Carmen Porter (https://carmenporter.com)

Awesome links:

https://goingtoseed.org/

https://lofthouse.com/

Transcript
Carmen:

Welcome to Song and Plants.

2

:

My name is Carmen Porter.

3

:

In this episode, I was joined by Joseph

Lofthouse to explore landrace gardening.

4

:

I decided to include this interview

in the Solanaceae series because it

5

:

seems that the majority of cultivar

development of this family of food crops

6

:

is heavily dominated by institutions

and their emerging technologies.

7

:

Joseph's book, Land Race Gardening,

Food Security Through Biodiversity

8

:

and Promiscuous Pollination,

however, makes cultivar selection

9

:

accessible and irresistible.

10

:

His book has inspired an online community

and organization that promote genetically

11

:

diverse seed saving practices, which

produce locally adapted resilient crops.

12

:

I hope you enjoy our conversation.

13

:

Welcome to Song and Plants.

14

:

Would you mind introducing yourself?

15

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Hi,

I'm Joseph Lofthouse.

16

:

I'm a farmer, plant breeder

that lives up in northern Utah.

17

:

And I'm a yogi.

18

:

I love dancing and singing.

19

:

And so it's beautiful to be on song

and dance, er, song and garden today.

20

:

Song and plants today.

21

:

Carmen: Excellent.

22

:

Well, thank you and welcome.

23

:

Landrace Gardening.

24

:

Would you mind giving a little overview

of what it is and how it works?

25

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, so land race

gardening is the idea of growing

26

:

plants in a location so that

27

:

they become adapted to the land and

the people that are living on the land.

28

:

And it really works beautifully.

29

:

Well, I define landrace gardening as

plants that are genetically diverse,

30

:

promiscuously pollinating, so that

they can adapt themselves to the local

31

:

ecosystem and the local human community.

32

:

Carmen: Fantastic.

33

:

How do you set up a landrace?

34

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, the

number one thing you need to be

35

:

doing is saving your own seeds.

36

:

Because then they can

become locally adapted.

37

:

And rather than trying to keep

things pure and inbred, if you

38

:

allow them to cross pollinate, they

adapt easier to the environment

39

:

and changes in the environment.

40

:

Carmen: So, Saving your seeds for

preserving a cultivar and developing a

41

:

land race, what would be the difference?

42

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, so the If

you're trying to preserve a cultivar,

43

:

what you're doing is inbreeding.

44

:

And every time we do inbreeding

on a plant, it becomes a little

45

:

bit weaker, a little bit less

able to deal with the ecosystem.

46

:

And so some of, like, our

beloved heirlooms have been

47

:

inbred for 50 years, 100 years.

48

:

And when I plant them in my garden, they

tend to do poorly, because my garden

49

:

is way different than the gardens

were a hundred years ago in Iowa or

50

:

wherever the heirloom was invented.

51

:

But when I allow those heirlooms to cross

pollinate with each other, then they

52

:

can rearrange their genetics and begin

to get comfortable in my garden again.

53

:

Carmen: So is it kind of like the

first stage, you're allowing them

54

:

to become hybrids, naturally?

55

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, so

naturally occurring hybrids , a

56

:

hybrid might actually do better

or worse in my ecosystem depending

57

:

on, what the parents were.

58

:

On average, the hybrids tend to

perform, like in tomatoes, about 50

59

:

percent better than the heirlooms.

60

:

And so if we're encouraging the natural

hybridization, then our crops tend to

61

:

be more reliable than the inbred crops.

62

:

Carmen: So would your setup be just

plant as much diversity as you can?

63

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I have

two different ways to go about it.

64

:

The first way like when I worked

on watermelon, I gathered the seeds

65

:

from 300 varieties of watermelon

and planted them all together.

66

:

You know, and I had five that actually

survived for me that first year.

67

:

But I also might do it by growing

my favorite squash and, it gets

68

:

cross pollinated by another squash

that isn't quite my favorite.

69

:

And then, you know, just gradual,

gradual select for what does good,

70

:

and especially for what I enjoy

eating, for what tastes lovely.

71

:

One of the big joys of landrace gardening,

or we also call it adaptation gardening,

72

:

is that the plants learn what I like

to eat, and they provide that for me.

73

:

And that partially happens because if

I'm saving seeds from every plant in

74

:

every generation, then I don't want to

save seeds from plants that taste bad.

75

:

I don't want to save seeds, like from a

squash that I can't cut with my knife.

76

:

So all this selection is going on.

77

:

And selection is also going on

for like the bugs and the climate

78

:

and my habits as a farmer.

79

:

And so the plants can really become

adapted to the local conditions

80

:

and my way of doing things.

81

:

My community's way of eating.

82

:

Carmen: And so in the first generation,

the ones that don't grow well just

83

:

won't survive and produce seed.

84

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Correct.

85

:

And sometimes they might put a little

bit of pollen into the patch, Even

86

:

if they didn't produce a seed, they

might put a little bit of pollen,

87

:

and so a trait from that pollen can

show up 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 years later.

88

:

But, generally in the first year,

what's totally unsuitable just dies.

89

:

And then in the second year, you get the

survivors crossing with the survivors.

90

:

And I think of the third year as

the magical year, because by then

91

:

you've got the best of the best

cross pollinating with each other.

92

:

And it can be really

joyful, that third year.

93

:

Carmen: And then how do you maintain it?

94

:

Because when you have those

crossing, do you have to continue

95

:

bringing in new genetics?

96

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I like

to bring in a little bit of

97

:

new genetics from time to time.

98

:

Like if I normally grow 20 squash

plants, I might plant one new

99

:

squash variety just to see if it

likes my garden, if I like it.

100

:

And if I don't, I just

don't save seeds from it.

101

:

But if I do, then I just fold it

in with all the rest of the squash.

102

:

So I like a little bit of diversity.

103

:

Another way I maintain diversity is

by trading seeds with my neighbors.

104

:

Because they're growing the same

species in approximately the same

105

:

climate, with the same habits.

106

:

And so, trading seeds with the neighbors

is another beautiful way to bring

107

:

genetic diversity into my garden.

108

:

Yeah.

109

:

Carmen: So it's a very different approach

in terms of there's no isolation.

110

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I do

a little bit of isolation.

111

:

For example, I don't like my sweet corn

and my popcorn to cross, because then I

112

:

get popcorn that doesn't pop, and I get

sweet corn that is hard and hard to chew.

113

:

And so, you know, I do minimal isolation.

114

:

But I don't isolate my red

sweet corn from my yellow sweet

115

:

corn from my white sweet corn.

116

:

And so my sweet corn ends up being a

mix of You know, just beautiful colors

117

:

and each of the colors has a different

flavor to it, and so I get all kinds of

118

:

joy and happiness out of the flavors.

119

:

And like in the melons, I

select for aromas that are

120

:

just beautiful and amazing.

121

:

So it ends up being really joyful

to eat food because I think part of

122

:

what's going on is if we're loving on

our plants, we're touching them with

123

:

our fingers, we're giving them our

microbes and our DNA, and I think they

124

:

hold onto that and give it back to us.

125

:

I think varieties that have, or,

only touched by metal, you know,

126

:

because the farmer never touches the

squash and never touches the seed.

127

:

And I think that those plants can't

give us as much joy as the plants

128

:

that we actually, you know, are

changing our microbiomes with.

129

:

Carmen: When you mentioned the

watermelons, how long did it take you to

130

:

start getting more than five watermelons?

131

:

Joseph Lofthouse: The second year

did better than the first year.

132

:

But watermelons in my climate are

way outside of their comfort zone.

133

:

And so they're one of those crops

that I'm always, they're always a

134

:

little bit of a struggle for me.

135

:

It's kind of like me

trying to grow an orange.

136

:

It's not going to happen outside

here, I would have to build

137

:

a greenhouse or something.

138

:

But for other crops like the squash

or the melons, the third year is

139

:

really the beautiful, magical year.

140

:

Like when I was growing cantaloupes, the

first year I planted thirty varieties,

141

:

and maybe five of them did okay for me.

142

:

But then the second year, I planted

about three hundred seeds, and there

143

:

were two plants that produced more than

all the rest of the patch combined.

144

:

You know, and then so the third

year, I was harvesting just bushels

145

:

and bushels of muskmelons and they

were ready way before my frost.

146

:

That works particularly

well with the melons because

147

:

they're an outcrossing species.

148

:

The species that are outcrossing are

rapidly rearranging their genetics.

149

:

And so they can really,

really change fast.

150

:

Where something like a, bean,

which is mostly inbreeding.

151

:

Like what happens with those is if I

plant a hundred varieties of beans,

152

:

95 of them just die the first year.

153

:

And then the other, you know, five

varieties, they just keep growing year

154

:

after year and they hardly ever cross.

155

:

But what I do in the case of the beans

is I just watch really carefully to

156

:

see if any natural crossing occurred.

157

:

And if I can identify a natural

cross, then I plant that

158

:

preferentially over the inbred beans.

159

:

Carmen: What would you be looking

for to identify a natural cross?

160

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, like if my

beans are always pink, but one year they

161

:

turn out pink with spots on them, you

know, then that would say, oh, here's

162

:

something new I've never saw before.

163

:

It's most likely a hybrid.

164

:

Carmen: You mentioned your

climate where exactly, like what

165

:

conditions are you dealing with?

166

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So, I live at 5, 000

feet elevation up in a mountain valley.

167

:

And it's in the desert, so I

have like 5 percent humidity

168

:

in the evenings, in the summer.

169

:

And the cold air comes down out of

the 9, 000 foot tall mountains that

170

:

are like less than 5 miles from

my garden, all summer, all winter.

171

:

My soil is like clay silt.

172

:

Probably technically it's

called the silty loam.

173

:

And so it really holds on to the

nutrients good, but it also has a pH

174

:

that's really high, and so that tends

to cause problems for some species.

175

:

Oh, and I have unlimited

irrigation water, basically.

176

:

Ha, ha, ha, ha.

177

:

Carmen: do you have a

hard freeze in the winter?

178

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, My

garden is covered with snow

179

:

between November to mid March.

180

:

And our low temperatures might be

around minus fifteen, minus twenty.

181

:

And because we're in a valley, the cold

air will come and it will sit like for

182

:

a week or something before the wind

blows and it warms up a little bit.

183

:

Carmen: What are some of the crops

that you have found to be the

184

:

most successful for land racing?

185

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So, anything

that is promiscuously pollinating.

186

:

So, that would be things like fava beans,

squash, melons, cucumbers, corn, any of

187

:

the brassicas, like that would be cabbage

and mustards and, kale, things like that.

188

:

Carmen: and promiscuously

189

:

pollinating?

190

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes.

191

:

So I use the term promiscuously

pollinating because there's a

192

:

term in the seed industry that

is called open pollinated.

193

:

And I want to distinguish what I'm

doing from open pollinated seeds.

194

:

Because, what open pollinated actually,

or what we think it means is like, Oh,

195

:

we don't really know who's the daddy.

196

:

You know, there could be...

197

:

but no, what it actually means is

we've done everything we know how

198

:

to do with cages and isolation

distances to prevent the crops from

199

:

actually crossing with each other.

200

:

They might technically cross with each

other, but if a clone crosses with a

201

:

clone, it's still a clone kind of idea.

202

:

And so I use the term promiscuously

pollinating because it says we

203

:

really do want to encourage that

things are cross pollinating.

204

:

Carmen: Another term that you

mentioned is male sterility.

205

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Eww, yeah.

206

:

Carmen: How

207

:

does that emerge?

208

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Okay, so The seed

industry likes to sell hybrids because

209

:

if they're selling a hybrid, then it's

basically proprietary, you need to

210

:

buy the seed every year from them.

211

:

And so with big fruited, or big seeded

things like squash that produce,

212

:

you know, hundreds of seeds with one

attempt to the pollination, you can

213

:

just do those pollinations by hand.

214

:

But if you start dealing with little

things like carrots or cabbages that

215

:

have these little teeny tiny flowers,

and they produce two or three or four

216

:

seeds, it's really hard to make a hybrid.

217

:

But, what the seed companies

discovered is they discovered if you

218

:

took, like the nucleus out of a say

a cabbage and put it into a carrot

219

:

that it wouldn't produce pollen.

220

:

And so you have a plant

that is male sterile.

221

:

And so then you can just grow a whole

bunch of seed and let the bees do

222

:

the cross pollination because all of

the pollen will come from a different

223

:

variety than the one that is sterile.

224

:

And, So, a lot of the

cabbages and the carrots

225

:

that

226

:

Joseph Lofthouse: are sold as hybrids are

actually using that sort of technology.

227

:

And I choose not to use that technology

in my garden because I like to know

228

:

that my flowers are complete, that

they have the male part and the

229

:

female part that's fully functional.

230

:

Carmen: So if you see it

emerged, you just cull them?

231

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, so when I

originally started growing carrots, I

232

:

just got carrots from the grocery store

and the seed catalog and, I planted

233

:

hybrid carrots and it turned out that

about seventy percent of my seeds

234

:

the next year had that sterile trait.

235

:

And you can see that because the,

flowers were missing the anthers.

236

:

And the anther is the part of the flower

that sheds pollen into the patch.

237

:

And so it was really easy for

me just to pull those out.

238

:

And if I miss a few, no big deal

because there's plenty of pollen

239

:

running around the patch and

they'll get pollinated anyway.

240

:

But it's just something that I watch

for and continuously remove as I see it.

241

:

Carmen: So if that genetics is in the mix,

it will continue into further generations?

242

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes.

243

:

And it's really complicated and biology

is fuzzy, but basically once that trait

244

:

gets into a line, it doesn't come out.

245

:

You can't get rid of it without, you

know, killing the plant kind of thing.

246

:

Carmen: But it tends to

be on small flowered...

247

:

Joseph Lofthouse: yes.

248

:

There are no commercial bean hybrids,

I think, because you cross pollinate

249

:

a bean and you get, you know,

three or four seeds kind of thing.

250

:

Carmen: In your book you talk

about the processing of beans.

251

:

Because I know some have problems

with beans, so do you mind just

252

:

touching on that for a second?

253

:

Because I found it really interesting.

254

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So the way that I grow

beans is I plant them all, all many

255

:

different varieties all jumbled up

together, and either the frost kills

256

:

them or they just die in the fall.

257

:

And I let them dry in the field, and

then I pull the whole plant, throw

258

:

it on a tarp, jump up and down on it,

dance if I'm feeling fun and joyful,

259

:

sing a song, and, and, and then You can

just scrape off the plant material and

260

:

the beans are left laying on the tarp.

261

:

And then you can dump them between

a couple of buckets while the wind is

262

:

blowing and all of the chaffy stuff

will fly away, leaving you with beans.

263

:

And then I need to sort them by

hand because sometimes I pull up a

264

:

little piece of the root that has

little pebbles on it or something.

265

:

And if I was being really careful, I

would cut the beans off at the root so

266

:

that I wasn't taking that soil with me.

267

:

And also if I'm being careful, I make

sure there's no pebbles in my shoes

268

:

when I jump up and down on them.

269

:

But usually what happens is I'm

harvesting the beans right before

270

:

a terrible storm is expected.

271

:

And So I'm rushed, and it's like,

just get it done, and we can sort

272

:

them in the kitchen a month from

now when it's warm and toasty.

273

:

Carmen: And you say that they have

poisons or they aren't very digestible.

274

:

So, what do you do?

275

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Beans have, I don't

know the name of the poison, but

276

:

they have a little bit of poison in.

277

:

And we have a long history as humans

of knowing how to deal with beans.

278

:

You soak them.

279

:

That takes some of the poisons out.

280

:

You cook them for a long time at high

temperature, that takes the poisons out.

281

:

But a lot of times, people that haven't

been trained in dealing with beans

282

:

that way, and they'll just take, like

a bean and grind it up and make a

283

:

flour out of it, and make a cookie,

and the cookie is barely cooked,

284

:

and you bite into that cookie and

the poison just pours out at you.

285

:

Maybe I'm a, what they call

a super taster, I don't know.

286

:

But, but those kinds of things are

really annoying to me because we've

287

:

known for thousands of years that

beans need to be cooked really well.

288

:

Well, yeah, so corn really

should be nixtamalized.

289

:

And that is cooking the

corn with an alkali.

290

:

What they call it, calcium

oxide or calcium hydroxide.

291

:

And what that does is it, eliminates a

lot of the toxins that come from mold.

292

:

And it also greatly increases

the vitamin content of the corn.

293

:

And so when corn got taken from the

native places where it was growing and

294

:

it went to the rest of the world, it

caused diseases in people because they

295

:

weren't treating it with the alkali first.

296

:

And, let's see, pellagra, I think

is the name of the disease that,

297

:

that came from replacing whatever

it was in their diet with corn

298

:

that hadn't been cooked in alkali.

299

:

And also another thing that cooking

in alkali does is it really enhances

300

:

the flavor of the flour corns.

301

:

Carmen: Do you find there are a lot of

different flavors between the colors?

302

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, there are.

303

:

And some people like one

color better than another.

304

:

And I tend to like a diversity

of colors, a diversity of flavors

305

:

more than I like just the same

old boring flavor every time.

306

:

Carmen: If you're doing a

patch of squash, are you going

307

:

to keep the species separate?

308

:

Joseph Lofthouse: No, I do not

keep species separate, and that is

309

:

because the definition of a species

is two varieties or two plants

310

:

that won't cross with each other.

311

:

And biology is fuzzy, and so once

in a while there will be a cross,

312

:

but I have only seen that, like,

one time in 15 years, between

313

:

the normal squash varieties.

314

:

There are two squash called the cushaws

and the moschatas, the butternuts and the

315

:

cushaws, and I think of them as not quite

separate species, because I have from

316

:

time to time seen a cross between those.

317

:

But for the most part, I just don't

observe that in my day to day gardening.

318

:

Carmen: So is there very

little separation in general?

319

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, because I am

trying to encourage cross pollination.

320

:

And so, pollination is highly localized.

321

:

And the best way to ensure cross

pollination is if two varieties

322

:

are growing side by side.

323

:

Because when a bee is visiting

flowers, it doesn't go from here, way

324

:

over there, and then back to here.

325

:

It goes from here, to the next closest

flower, to the next closest flower.

326

:

So the closer we interplant things

that can cross pollinate, the more

327

:

likely they are to actually cross.

328

:

Carmen: So would that mean that

things that are self fertile you

329

:

would plant very close together

to try and encourage crossing?

330

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, for example, beans

in my garden, they cross about 1 in 200.

331

:

They can cross like 1 in 20, if

they're growing in an ecosystem,

332

:

like by a swamp next to a forest

that has all kinds of pollinators

333

:

that are coming into the garden.

334

:

But out here in the desert , my

chances of cross pollination

335

:

are much less on, beans.

336

:

But my chances of cross

pollination, like on wheat, are

337

:

higher because lower humidity

favors cross pollination on wheat.

338

:

So, it's a mixed bag, but the

closer you plant things together,

339

:

the more likely they are to cross.

340

:

And, to go the other way about

it, if you want things not to

341

:

cross, plant them further apart.

342

:

For example, with my squash, I

tend to plant the orange squash

343

:

on one end of the row and the green

squash on the other end of the row.

344

:

So the oranges will mostly cross

pollinate with the oranges.

345

:

The greens will mostly cross

pollinate with the greens.

346

:

And then where they meet, I

end up with striped squash.

347

:

And so, we can go both

ways with our pollination.

348

:

Carmen: And what kind of traits

are you looking for in your squash?

349

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So, the number one

trait that I always select for, well,

350

:

there's two that I always select for.

351

:

First is productivity.

352

:

It has to produce fruit in my garden.

353

:

And the second is flavor.

354

:

It just has to taste

beautiful and delightful.

355

:

I inadvertently selected for squash

that are easy to cut, because I

356

:

was tasting every squash for years

before I saved seeds from it.

357

:

And if it was hard to cut, I

was just composting it rather

358

:

than saving seeds from it.

359

:

And that was totally inadvertent.

360

:

I didn't know I was doing it,

but when I realized it's like, oh

361

:

yeah, you get what you select for.

362

:

And then there are other traits show

up sometimes that might be interesting.

363

:

For example, one time I found a squash

that had a fuzzy skin, and it's like,

364

:

whoa, you know, what if the fuzz

kept a deer from eating it, or kept

365

:

a rat from eating it, or what if the

fuzz, irritated the squash bugs?

366

:

You know, and there's all kinds of

possibilities about things that you

367

:

might see that might be useful later on.

368

:

And I never did anything with that

squash, but it was interesting

369

:

to think about the possibilities.

370

:

Carmen: When you were starting

your, melon land race, did you

371

:

have all different colors or were

they all orange cantaloupe type?

372

:

Joseph Lofthouse: They were all

cantaloupe types that I started with.

373

:

Some green fleshed ones came

into the population at one point,

374

:

and later on I did a separate

population with green fleshed melons.

375

:

So, there was just a lot to explore

there, and I didn't ever explore

376

:

like the Armenian Cucumber types,

and I didn't explore the, what

377

:

they call them, Casabas types.

378

:

You know, so there would be a

lot that someone could do with

379

:

melons that I haven't ever done.

380

:

Carmen: What about the Solanaceae family?

381

:

Have you done much

playing around with them?

382

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, so, the

most popular page on my website

383

:

is actually about growing

potatoes from pollinated seeds.

384

:

And that's been the most

popular page for like 15 years.

385

:

And, What you can get is you can

just get a lot of beautiful varieties

386

:

and colors and flavors that come

out of, out of those crosses.

387

:

My favorite solanaceae, ooh, big word,

388

:

is the tomatoes.

389

:

And I was trying to breed with tomatoes

and I was just having a dickens of a time.

390

:

And So I did a deep dive into the

genetics of tomatoes, and it turns out

391

:

that 95 percent of the genetics got left

in the wild when they were domesticated,

392

:

because a few tomato plants went from

the Andes Mountains up to Mexico, and

393

:

then a few plants went from Mexico

to Europe, then they sent tomatoes

394

:

from Europe to the rest of the world.

395

:

And each time that the tomatoes

traveled, they didn't take

396

:

their pollinators with them.

397

:

And so that encouraged them

to become self pollinating.

398

:

And they just shed all kinds of

genetic diversity that didn't

399

:

get taken with them as well.

400

:

And so, One day I was in my tomato

patch I was doing frost tolerance

401

:

trials, planting 30 varieties and

seeing which ones did the best

402

:

in the cold and with the frost.

403

:

And there was one tomato plant, anytime

I went to my garden, there was a

404

:

bumblebee on exactly that one plant.

405

:

And it got me thinking we could turn

tomatoes into a cross pollinating species

406

:

instead of a self pollinating species.

407

:

And it turns out that in the

Andes, they grow primarily

408

:

as cross pollinating species.

409

:

Not only cross pollinating,

but 100 percent cross

410

:

pollinating every single time.

411

:

And so those tomatoes that do that

are green fruited, and the flavor

412

:

is Not something you'd want to eat.

413

:

But!

414

:

So I crossed those tomatoes with domestic

tomatoes and, what I found was I found

415

:

amazing flavors and amazing aromas.

416

:

So, I thought I was going to do a project

to select for promiscuous flowers.

417

:

And yes, that's one of the

primary goals of the project.

418

:

But what I'm really chasing is fruits

that taste like guava, and, sea

419

:

urchin, and melon, and citrus.

420

:

Just these glorious, beautiful

flavors that make my heart sing.

421

:

And, uh, ha, ha, ha.

422

:

And, and so, the tomato project has

come to define my work as a farmer.

423

:

'Cause I'm getting older, my ability

and my ambition are failing, but the

424

:

Promiscuous Tomato Project just sings to

my heart and just brings me so much joy.

425

:

And so that's the one I just hang

on to with everything I have.

426

:

Carmen: What does the flower look like?

427

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Oh, so in a domestic

tomato, the flowers are about half

428

:

inch in diameter, just these little

things and they're pale colored.

429

:

Some of the promiscuous tomato flowers

are like an inch and three quarters

430

:

across, just these big flowers with

tremendous numbers of petals, and

431

:

they're brightly colored, and they have

the style, which is the part that's

432

:

receptive to pollen, is on the outside

of the flower, so it can attract, or

433

:

it can rub against the belly of a bee.

434

:

Oftentimes, a whole flower cluster

will open up one day, and there are

435

:

these big fist sized flower clusters

that are way up above the foliage

436

:

so the bees can really get to them.

437

:

They're just joyful and beautiful, besides

having all these flavors and aromas

438

:

that we'd never expect from a tomato.

439

:

Carmen: What happens

in terms of the color?

440

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So, I have been

selecting for orange colored tomatoes,

441

:

because when I do blind taste testing

with people, they almost invariably

442

:

prefer the flavors of the orange

tomatoes over any other color.

443

:

I think the orange color in the tomatoes

is due to beta carotene, and beta carotene

444

:

is converted to vitamin A in the body.

445

:

And so I think people just

inherently, their bodies inherently

446

:

know what's good for them.

447

:

And one time when we were doing a

taste testing, I thought I'd be a

448

:

smart aleck and I went and picked one

of the domestic tomatoes out of the

449

:

field and brought it in and cut it.

450

:

And after we tasted it, the guy

that was hosting us went to the

451

:

kitchen and got a rag and came and

washed the cutting board so that it

452

:

wouldn't contaminate the flavor of the

tomatoes we're going to taste next.

453

:

Carmen: What happened for size?

454

:

Joseph Lofthouse: I have been

selecting for tomatoes that are

455

:

about the size of a ping pong ball.

456

:

Call them saladettes or as

big as, four to six ounces.

457

:

And that is partly due to my

ecosystem because I have about

458

:

90 to 100 frost free days.

459

:

And so I have to select for tomatoes

that jump out of the ground.

460

:

They really grow fast and they ripen fast.

461

:

And the smaller tomatoes tend to do that

quicker than the great big tomatoes.

462

:

Someone in a warmer climate with longer

growing season could make other choices.

463

:

Carmen: It's quite a short growing season.

464

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Ha ha ha.

465

:

So, if I buy tomatoes from a

seed catalog, 95 percent of them

466

:

will fail for me because of the

shortness of the growing season.

467

:

Basically, I can grow tomatoes that the

seed catalogs call maybe up to 70 days.

468

:

But I'm better off with 55 or

60 day tomatoes, which leaves

469

:

me hardly any to choose from.

470

:

Carmen: In your initial planting

of squash, did you select

471

:

ones that were short season?

472

:

Joseph Lofthouse: What I find is

that the ecosystem does like 80

473

:

percent of the selection for me.

474

:

So the first year that I planted

butternut squash, I planted, oh, maybe 10

475

:

varieties, and only, like, two or three

of them actually produced fruit for me.

476

:

And my growing season

that year was 88 days.

477

:

And then, I think two years later,

the growing season was 84 days long.

478

:

And so the ecosystem selected heavy,

heavy, heavy for quick maturity.

479

:

And what that does when I send my seeds to

someplace like, down south, my plants jump

480

:

out of the ground, they grow like crazy,

they produce fruit, and then they die from

481

:

the diseases and the pests and whatever.

482

:

But they've already produced an

abundant harvest, so it doesn't matter.

483

:

And then down south they

can plant a second crop.

484

:

Carmen: Can you harvest the

seed from fruit that's not quite

485

:

mature in your first season?

486

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, you can.

487

:

Seeds tend to be viable a long time

before they're totally mature.

488

:

And so you can harvest seeds from

very immature fruits, and they

489

:

still often will produce seeds.

490

:

And so, on my melons, that's what

happened the first year I planted them.

491

:

I harvested only immature melons.

492

:

But then, two years later, I

was harvesting melons weeks

493

:

before my fall frosts.

494

:

Carmen: So even though the parents

would have not made it through the

495

:

growing season, just by growing

them there, the genetics adapted?

496

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, some of

the parents did make it through.

497

:

And, like, 80 percent of the parents

didn't survive, didn't produce seeds.

498

:

I can't really look at a seed catalog

and trust that, that it's going

499

:

to actually apply to my garden.

500

:

And so, I just end up randomly trying

varieties and what survives, shows that

501

:

it was capable of surviving in my garden.

502

:

And then, you mix up the genetics

of those, and you give them another

503

:

chance, and some of them are

better, capable of surviving even

504

:

better than their parents did.

505

:

Carmen: And something else that you

mentioned is keeping the old seed and

506

:

reintroducing it from previous seasons.

507

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, and the reason

I do that is because the climate

508

:

here in the mountains is variable.

509

:

Some years we'll have drought,

some years we'll have extra rainy,

510

:

some years will be super hot,

some years will be kind of cool.

511

:

And I save seeds from multiple years so

that I tend to get an average of what

512

:

did good over all of those different

growing conditions, rather than having

513

:

my whole population shift towards the

wet loving group or the dry loving group.

514

:

Hedging my bets kind of deal.

515

:

Carmen: So would that be

from like two years previous

516

:

or what's the sort of process?

517

:

Joseph Lofthouse: well for

me I keep a jar of seeds.

518

:

Like 80 percent of that jar of

seeds will be new seeds and 20

519

:

percent will be from previous years.

520

:

But I don't, you know

I don't make a formula.

521

:

I don't try to control that

and be in charge of it.

522

:

I just make sure that there's some

older seed that's always hanging around.

523

:

Carmen: Does your population or your

plantation have to be really large

524

:

or can you scale a land race down?

525

:

Joseph Lofthouse: You can scale

a landrace down because we're

526

:

encouraging genetic diversity.

527

:

And the reason to have large

populations is because the crops

528

:

were so inbred that they were having

problems with being too inbred.

529

:

And In one cob of my sweet corn, there's

more genetic diversity than, like, 10,

530

:

000 acres worth of commercial sweet corn.

531

:

And, ha ha ha, and, and so, small

scale, people can really grow landraces

532

:

effectively, especially if you're sharing

seeds with your neighbors, if you're

533

:

allowing promiscuous pollination, If

you bring in a new variety once in a

534

:

while, then you can avoid those sort

of problems that inbreeding created

535

:

in the open pollinated seed movement.

536

:

Carmen: Touching back into

the Solanaceae for a second.

537

:

Have you done any with

tomatillos or ground cherries?

538

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, I love

tomatillos because they have the

539

:

100 percent outcrossing trait.

540

:

And what that means is that when

somebody plants tomatillos in their

541

:

garden, They become a weed in just a

year or two, and they never go away.

542

:

You can't get rid of them.

543

:

And I would love for tomatoes to end up

with that same sort of breeding system.

544

:

And this last summer, I went on

a hike up in the mountains, and

545

:

we have a local ground cherry.

546

:

And I selected Well, not a bunch

of seeds, I worked really hard

547

:

for a few little hints of a seed.

548

:

But I'm growing those this

year and intending to introduce

549

:

those into my garden as well.

550

:

Carmen: I can't help but wonder

why there aren't more varieties

551

:

or more projects developing them.

552

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well for me, I see

them everywhere because I wrote a

553

:

book and a movement started about it.

554

:

And so But, a bunch of my readers

got together and they made a non profit

555

:

organization called Going to Seed.

556

:

They came to my garden and made videos

about me talking about land race

557

:

gardening and people donated enough

money to make those videos free.

558

:

They made a, forum to talk about it.

559

:

the Cliff Family Foundation donated

like 25, 000 so that we could support

560

:

farmers in learning to grow this

way, and so about a dozen farmers are

561

:

developing land races of various species.

562

:

And so for me, I'm right in

the middle of everything, but

563

:

Carmen: you said that's goingtoseed...

564

:

Joseph Lofthouse: goingtoseed.org

565

:

Carmen: org.

566

:

I'll put that in the show notes.

567

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Thank you.

568

:

Carmen: Along with any other

links that you give me.

569

:

You also mentioned potatoes.

570

:

So, true seed potatoes.

571

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So, so, the

favorite potato that I ever found by

572

:

growing from seeds, the tubers were

about the size of a ping pong ball.

573

:

But each plant would produce like

a gallon of these little tubers.

574

:

And they were so beautiful to rinse

off and take to the farmer's market.

575

:

Carmen: neat.

576

:

What color were they?

577

:

Joseph Lofthouse: They were a red

potato with a white inside, but some

578

:

of the potatoes were just beautiful

like they'd be yellow inside with

579

:

a blue skin, or they'd be a white

inside with red streaks through them.

580

:

Just a whole bunch of diversity.

581

:

Carmen: When you started with

the potatoes, did you have

582

:

difficulty getting them to flower?

583

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, yes,

sorta, because potatoes are

584

:

typically grown by cloning and

every time you clone something,

585

:

it damages the DNA a little bit.

586

:

And so most of the potatoes that people

grow are not capable of producing flowers.

587

:

And so, we had to select for varieties

that were capable of producing flowers

588

:

in the first place, and then once

those start crossing with each other,

589

:

then they remember how to produce

flowers and they produce a lot of seed.

590

:

But, those first years of finding

varieties that can produce

591

:

seeds is kind of troubling.

592

:

The same thing happens with

Like garlic and onions.

593

:

If you've been growing a variety

that's a clone, it often

594

:

has forgotten how to flower.

595

:

But once they start crossing with each

other, then they remember how to flower.

596

:

And they flower more reliably.

597

:

And on onions, the reliable

flowering lasts for about 10 years.

598

:

And then they start to

forget how to flower again.

599

:

Carmen: That's pretty interesting.

600

:

What about spinach?

601

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Oh, spinach is nice

because it has male plants and female

602

:

plants, and so you could create your own

hybrids if you had two varieties and you

603

:

wanted to cross them with each other.

604

:

It'd just be a matter of watching

early in the season and chopping

605

:

out the female plants in one row and

the male plants in the other row.

606

:

Spinach is, for me, is one of those

crops where you plant ten varieties

607

:

and half of them are just going

to fail totally, and half of them

608

:

are going to be beautiful plants.

609

:

Carmen: How do you deal with things

like carrots and beets being biennial?

610

:

Joseph Lofthouse: It's hard, because

I live in a super cold climate, and so

611

:

I can't really leave them out in the

elements, and so I have to either mulch

612

:

them really heavily so that maybe they

survive and maybe they rot because of the

613

:

mulch, or I bring them inside and try to

keep them alive in a refrigerator, but

614

:

that takes up my space, or, you know,

in a garage, but that's kind of iffy,

615

:

and so the biennials are rough on me.

616

:

It would be nice if I could

select for varieties that

617

:

could handle the outside cold.

618

:

I have done that on a few things,

like I developed a variety of

619

:

kale that can survive my winters.

620

:

Then that makes the biennials

easier to deal with.

621

:

Carmen: In terms of pests,

you mentioned brassica family.

622

:

ha.

623

:

Is it just selecting for what can survive?

624

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, and I don't do

any kind of spraying or poisoning or

625

:

killing of the pests, because I consider

them to be blessings to my garden.

626

:

They're teaching my plants how

to be strong, how to survive, how

627

:

to collaborate with each other.

628

:

And so I hardly even know that I have

a pest in my garden or a disease.

629

:

I remember one time a lady asked if

she could grow a little garden in my

630

:

field, and I'm like, sure, go ahead.

631

:

So she bought some squash from the

seed company and she planted it and

632

:

the squash bugs just pounced on it and

all kinds of diseases started affecting

633

:

the foliage and it was just terrible.

634

:

And.

635

:

I know they say you're not supposed to

laugh at other people's misery, but I

636

:

was so happy and joyful that her plants

just died like that because it, it

637

:

showed me that those pests and diseases

are in my garden, but they've learned

638

:

to live in harmony with the plants.

639

:

And so it was just a,

beautiful experience for me.

640

:

And I'm sorry for the

plant's misery, but laughs

641

:

Carmen: Even things like the

caterpillars on the brassicas?

642

:

Joseph Lofthouse: I don't really

notice much of a problem with them.

643

:

I know that if I grow red brassicas,

that they're more resistant to the

644

:

caterpillars because the the predator

can see the green caterpillars on the

645

:

red cabbage, and it's less of a problem.

646

:

Carmen: Would you also be looking for

less wrinkly kale, that sort of thing?

647

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, well, for

example, on spinach one time I, I

648

:

took a puckery leaf spinach to my

sister and she cooked it and it was

649

:

totally filled with little wireworms.

650

:

And I was so horrified and so I

started selecting for spinach that had

651

:

perfectly smooth leaves so that there

would be no place for the bugs to hide.

652

:

I imagine that similar types of

strategies can be used with the

653

:

brassicas and the cabbage moths.

654

:

Carmen: How do these plants

adjust to your style of gardening?

655

:

What traits have you noticed that emerge

that really show your style of gardening?

656

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I can

think of a tomato as an example.

657

:

Because I grow tomatoes

sprawling on the ground.

658

:

And they're just in the dirt.

659

:

I don't try to protect them or trellis

them or not even really weed them.

660

:

And so a neighbor asked me how I could

grow tomatoes that are so clean and,

661

:

and I'm like, that's just how they grow.

662

:

But then I started paying attention, and

I had been saving tomato seeds only from

663

:

the tomatoes that were beautiful tomatoes.

664

:

I wasn't saving seeds from those that

had got in the dirt and rotted, and turns

665

:

out that the tomato vines had developed

an arching architecture to their vines.

666

:

So the vine would go up and make a

little bridge kind of thing that the

667

:

fruits could hang up off the ground.

668

:

And then that kept them clean

and it kept them from rotting.

669

:

And I didn't intend to do that.

670

:

It's just one of those things that

they adapted to my way of doing things.

671

:

And I find that over and over again,

the plants are figuring out my way of

672

:

doing things and adapting to it even

if I'm not consciously aware of what

673

:

I'm doing or what they're adapting to.

674

:

For example, on my beans, because I do the

stomping harvest, pretty much, any bean

675

:

that is like green when I do that stomp

, I'm not going to save seeds from it.

676

:

And so I've inadvertently selected

for seeds or for beans that I can

677

:

harvest all on one day, they're ready

before my fall frost or right with it.

678

:

So I inadvertently selected for

uniformity of harvest time for example.

679

:

Where somebody that was growing a

pole bean and they were harvesting

680

:

one pod at a time, they would be

selecting for a longer harvest window.

681

:

Carmen: And if you come across a

particular fruit, whether it be a

682

:

melon or a squash, and it's just, or

a tomato, and it's just so delicious.

683

:

Do you isolate it or do you

continue it in the landrace?

684

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So typically what

I'll do is I'll save seeds from that

685

:

separately, and I'll plant more of

that next year, or I'll plant it in

686

:

a corner of the garden so I can see

how it's going to perform, if the

687

:

beautiful flavor is still there.

688

:

And if I like that a lot, then I might

save more seeds from that next year and

689

:

less from the ones I don't like as much.

690

:

So, yeah, I'm constantly paying

attention to what I love and

691

:

encouraging more of that.

692

:

Carmen: You mention in your

book, singing to your plants.

693

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Uh huh.

694

:

Carmen: Would you mind,

perhaps sharing a song?

695

:

Joseph Lofthouse: I would love to.

696

:

So I'm going to switch my microphone.

697

:

I often sing this song to my plants

in my garden, and it reminds me

698

:

that I am part of the ecosystem,

and the ecosystem is part of me.

699

:

And it goes like this.

700

:

May all beings, everywhere,

all be happy and free.

701

:

In Sanskrit, the words are

Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu

702

:

May all beings everywhere

all be happy and free.

703

:

May all beings everywhere

all be happy and free.

704

:

May all beings everywhere

all be happy and free.

705

:

Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu

706

:

Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu

707

:

Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu

708

:

May all beings everywhere

all be happy and free.

709

:

May all beings everywhere

all be happy and free.

710

:

Carmen: Thank you.

711

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Thank you, Carmen.

712

:

Carmen: So I've mentioned

your book a number of times.

713

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Mm-Hmm.

714

:

Carmen: Would you mind letting

people know where they can find it?

715

:

How they can find you?

716

:

Joseph Lofthouse: So, I spend

most of my online time talking

717

:

about adaptation gardening, land

race gardening, at goingtoseed.

718

:

org.

719

:

My book is available wherever books

are sold, including, like, Amazon,

720

:

and Barnes Noble, and Target.

721

:

Landrace race Gardening, Food

security through biodiversity

722

:

and promiscuous pollination.

723

:

It could also be subtitled like

how to grow food without buying

724

:

seeds, fertilizers, or poisons.

725

:

Carmen: when you're talking about tasting

everything and how you can taste poisons.

726

:

Plants do produce these poisons, but

you taste every plant or every fruit

727

:

that you're going to save seed from.

728

:

Joseph Lofthouse: I made myself so

sick one day by tasting lettuce.

729

:

Carmen: So thank you very, very much for,

730

:

for joining me.

731

:

Actually, I do have one other

little question about the squash.

732

:

So I do have a hybrid that

has naturally emerged.

733

:

I have a tendency to let things self seed

and when they come up I let them grow.

734

:

And I had a hybrid that came up in a

year that my squash were absolutely

735

:

decimated by the squash vine borer.

736

:

And it came up on the compost pile

and it looks like it's a cross

737

:

between moschata and probably maxima.

738

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Okay.

739

:

Carmen: And the vines were hard, but the

fruit looked a lot more like a maxima.

740

:

And the flesh was absolutely

delicious, and it produced so many

741

:

fruit when all of the others died.

742

:

But there were barely

any seeds in the fruit.

743

:

So I saved them all, and I've

been planting them out for the

744

:

next two years, but I haven't

gotten that trait to come back.

745

:

Joseph Lofthouse: yeah, so, interspecies

hybrids are often not very fertile.

746

:

I've seen that a few times when

I've tried making those crosses.

747

:

If you ever find an offspring that has

that little thin vine that will resist

748

:

the borers, and it has the beautiful

flavor of the maxima, then woo hoo!

749

:

Right.

750

:

Carmen: If you can get it to come

back in the future generations,

751

:

that was the problem that I had.

752

:

I keep trying.

753

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Offspring tend

to resemble their parents and

754

:

their grandparents, but sometimes

the trait skips a generation.

755

:

Carmen: So I just have to keep trying

756

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah.

757

:

There is a squash that's an interspecies

hybrid called Tetsuka Buto, which is

758

:

sold by Pine Tree Garden Seeds, and

that is halfway in between a moschata

759

:

and a maxima already, and So that

might be a place for you to look.

760

:

Carmen: To bring that one into my race.

761

:

Joseph Lofthouse: huh.

762

:

Carmen: Well, thanks again.

763

:

I really appreciated the conversation.

764

:

It's been lovely.

765

:

Joseph Lofthouse: Thank you, Carmen.

766

:

Carmen: Thanks for listening.

767

:

If there's anyone that you would like to

hear included in the Solanaceae series,

768

:

please don't hesitate to let me know.

769

:

I always love hearing your thoughts,

comments, and inspirations.

770

:

Just head over to CarmenPorter.

771

:

com to connect.

772

:

Happy garden dreaming.

All Episodes Previous Episode
Show artwork for Song and Plants

About the Podcast

Song and Plants
Botanical musings and music
Learning the binomial nomenclature (scientific names) of biota is a fascinating way to glean insight into the natural world. Though daunting at first, they can become familiar and accessible with the help of melody and context. This podcast will present tunes where the scientific names of species comprise the lyrical content. Episodes will describe habitats, growing conditions, nutritional information, and locate species within their taxonomic hierarchy. Historical significance, interviews and anecdotal stories will also be presented. Each musical release will inspire eight weekly episodes. Come grow with me!

About your host

Profile picture for Carmen Porter

Carmen Porter

Growing up, my playground was the forest and orchard behind my house which were teeming with fascinating flora and fauna. I was the little girl singing to her extensive plant collection and pet caterpillars. After leaving home for too many years to pursue higher education and wander around the world, I returned to plant a garden. There are currently more than 500 cultivars of fruits and vegetables growing around my house.

'Song and Plants' came about when I started writing music to help me learn the binomial nomenclature (scientific names) of local biota. The podcast accompanies the tunes by providing information that extends beyond the lyrical content.