Episode 37
Landrace Gardening with Joseph Lofthouse!
What is a land race? How is promiscuous pollination different from open pollinated? How do you maintain diversity over multiple seasons? Can a land race be scaled down successfully to flourish in a home garden? Does Joseph Lofthouse sing beautifully? All this and so much more in this episode of Song and Plants!
Opening tune: Solanaceae by Carmen Porter (https://carmenporter.com)
Awesome links:
Transcript
Welcome to Song and Plants.
2
:My name is Carmen Porter.
3
:In this episode, I was joined by Joseph
Lofthouse to explore landrace gardening.
4
:I decided to include this interview
in the Solanaceae series because it
5
:seems that the majority of cultivar
development of this family of food crops
6
:is heavily dominated by institutions
and their emerging technologies.
7
:Joseph's book, Land Race Gardening,
Food Security Through Biodiversity
8
:and Promiscuous Pollination,
however, makes cultivar selection
9
:accessible and irresistible.
10
:His book has inspired an online community
and organization that promote genetically
11
:diverse seed saving practices, which
produce locally adapted resilient crops.
12
:I hope you enjoy our conversation.
13
:Welcome to Song and Plants.
14
:Would you mind introducing yourself?
15
:Joseph Lofthouse: Hi,
I'm Joseph Lofthouse.
16
:I'm a farmer, plant breeder
that lives up in northern Utah.
17
:And I'm a yogi.
18
:I love dancing and singing.
19
:And so it's beautiful to be on song
and dance, er, song and garden today.
20
:Song and plants today.
21
:Carmen: Excellent.
22
:Well, thank you and welcome.
23
:Landrace Gardening.
24
:Would you mind giving a little overview
of what it is and how it works?
25
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, so land race
gardening is the idea of growing
26
:plants in a location so that
27
:they become adapted to the land and
the people that are living on the land.
28
:And it really works beautifully.
29
:Well, I define landrace gardening as
plants that are genetically diverse,
30
:promiscuously pollinating, so that
they can adapt themselves to the local
31
:ecosystem and the local human community.
32
:Carmen: Fantastic.
33
:How do you set up a landrace?
34
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, the
number one thing you need to be
35
:doing is saving your own seeds.
36
:Because then they can
become locally adapted.
37
:And rather than trying to keep
things pure and inbred, if you
38
:allow them to cross pollinate, they
adapt easier to the environment
39
:and changes in the environment.
40
:Carmen: So, Saving your seeds for
preserving a cultivar and developing a
41
:land race, what would be the difference?
42
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, so the If
you're trying to preserve a cultivar,
43
:what you're doing is inbreeding.
44
:And every time we do inbreeding
on a plant, it becomes a little
45
:bit weaker, a little bit less
able to deal with the ecosystem.
46
:And so some of, like, our
beloved heirlooms have been
47
:inbred for 50 years, 100 years.
48
:And when I plant them in my garden, they
tend to do poorly, because my garden
49
:is way different than the gardens
were a hundred years ago in Iowa or
50
:wherever the heirloom was invented.
51
:But when I allow those heirlooms to cross
pollinate with each other, then they
52
:can rearrange their genetics and begin
to get comfortable in my garden again.
53
:Carmen: So is it kind of like the
first stage, you're allowing them
54
:to become hybrids, naturally?
55
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, so
naturally occurring hybrids , a
56
:hybrid might actually do better
or worse in my ecosystem depending
57
:on, what the parents were.
58
:On average, the hybrids tend to
perform, like in tomatoes, about 50
59
:percent better than the heirlooms.
60
:And so if we're encouraging the natural
hybridization, then our crops tend to
61
:be more reliable than the inbred crops.
62
:Carmen: So would your setup be just
plant as much diversity as you can?
63
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I have
two different ways to go about it.
64
:The first way like when I worked
on watermelon, I gathered the seeds
65
:from 300 varieties of watermelon
and planted them all together.
66
:You know, and I had five that actually
survived for me that first year.
67
:But I also might do it by growing
my favorite squash and, it gets
68
:cross pollinated by another squash
that isn't quite my favorite.
69
:And then, you know, just gradual,
gradual select for what does good,
70
:and especially for what I enjoy
eating, for what tastes lovely.
71
:One of the big joys of landrace gardening,
or we also call it adaptation gardening,
72
:is that the plants learn what I like
to eat, and they provide that for me.
73
:And that partially happens because if
I'm saving seeds from every plant in
74
:every generation, then I don't want to
save seeds from plants that taste bad.
75
:I don't want to save seeds, like from a
squash that I can't cut with my knife.
76
:So all this selection is going on.
77
:And selection is also going on
for like the bugs and the climate
78
:and my habits as a farmer.
79
:And so the plants can really become
adapted to the local conditions
80
:and my way of doing things.
81
:My community's way of eating.
82
:Carmen: And so in the first generation,
the ones that don't grow well just
83
:won't survive and produce seed.
84
:Joseph Lofthouse: Correct.
85
:And sometimes they might put a little
bit of pollen into the patch, Even
86
:if they didn't produce a seed, they
might put a little bit of pollen,
87
:and so a trait from that pollen can
show up 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 years later.
88
:But, generally in the first year,
what's totally unsuitable just dies.
89
:And then in the second year, you get the
survivors crossing with the survivors.
90
:And I think of the third year as
the magical year, because by then
91
:you've got the best of the best
cross pollinating with each other.
92
:And it can be really
joyful, that third year.
93
:Carmen: And then how do you maintain it?
94
:Because when you have those
crossing, do you have to continue
95
:bringing in new genetics?
96
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I like
to bring in a little bit of
97
:new genetics from time to time.
98
:Like if I normally grow 20 squash
plants, I might plant one new
99
:squash variety just to see if it
likes my garden, if I like it.
100
:And if I don't, I just
don't save seeds from it.
101
:But if I do, then I just fold it
in with all the rest of the squash.
102
:So I like a little bit of diversity.
103
:Another way I maintain diversity is
by trading seeds with my neighbors.
104
:Because they're growing the same
species in approximately the same
105
:climate, with the same habits.
106
:And so, trading seeds with the neighbors
is another beautiful way to bring
107
:genetic diversity into my garden.
108
:Yeah.
109
:Carmen: So it's a very different approach
in terms of there's no isolation.
110
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I do
a little bit of isolation.
111
:For example, I don't like my sweet corn
and my popcorn to cross, because then I
112
:get popcorn that doesn't pop, and I get
sweet corn that is hard and hard to chew.
113
:And so, you know, I do minimal isolation.
114
:But I don't isolate my red
sweet corn from my yellow sweet
115
:corn from my white sweet corn.
116
:And so my sweet corn ends up being a
mix of You know, just beautiful colors
117
:and each of the colors has a different
flavor to it, and so I get all kinds of
118
:joy and happiness out of the flavors.
119
:And like in the melons, I
select for aromas that are
120
:just beautiful and amazing.
121
:So it ends up being really joyful
to eat food because I think part of
122
:what's going on is if we're loving on
our plants, we're touching them with
123
:our fingers, we're giving them our
microbes and our DNA, and I think they
124
:hold onto that and give it back to us.
125
:I think varieties that have, or,
only touched by metal, you know,
126
:because the farmer never touches the
squash and never touches the seed.
127
:And I think that those plants can't
give us as much joy as the plants
128
:that we actually, you know, are
changing our microbiomes with.
129
:Carmen: When you mentioned the
watermelons, how long did it take you to
130
:start getting more than five watermelons?
131
:Joseph Lofthouse: The second year
did better than the first year.
132
:But watermelons in my climate are
way outside of their comfort zone.
133
:And so they're one of those crops
that I'm always, they're always a
134
:little bit of a struggle for me.
135
:It's kind of like me
trying to grow an orange.
136
:It's not going to happen outside
here, I would have to build
137
:a greenhouse or something.
138
:But for other crops like the squash
or the melons, the third year is
139
:really the beautiful, magical year.
140
:Like when I was growing cantaloupes, the
first year I planted thirty varieties,
141
:and maybe five of them did okay for me.
142
:But then the second year, I planted
about three hundred seeds, and there
143
:were two plants that produced more than
all the rest of the patch combined.
144
:You know, and then so the third
year, I was harvesting just bushels
145
:and bushels of muskmelons and they
were ready way before my frost.
146
:That works particularly
well with the melons because
147
:they're an outcrossing species.
148
:The species that are outcrossing are
rapidly rearranging their genetics.
149
:And so they can really,
really change fast.
150
:Where something like a, bean,
which is mostly inbreeding.
151
:Like what happens with those is if I
plant a hundred varieties of beans,
152
:95 of them just die the first year.
153
:And then the other, you know, five
varieties, they just keep growing year
154
:after year and they hardly ever cross.
155
:But what I do in the case of the beans
is I just watch really carefully to
156
:see if any natural crossing occurred.
157
:And if I can identify a natural
cross, then I plant that
158
:preferentially over the inbred beans.
159
:Carmen: What would you be looking
for to identify a natural cross?
160
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, like if my
beans are always pink, but one year they
161
:turn out pink with spots on them, you
know, then that would say, oh, here's
162
:something new I've never saw before.
163
:It's most likely a hybrid.
164
:Carmen: You mentioned your
climate where exactly, like what
165
:conditions are you dealing with?
166
:Joseph Lofthouse: So, I live at 5, 000
feet elevation up in a mountain valley.
167
:And it's in the desert, so I
have like 5 percent humidity
168
:in the evenings, in the summer.
169
:And the cold air comes down out of
the 9, 000 foot tall mountains that
170
:are like less than 5 miles from
my garden, all summer, all winter.
171
:My soil is like clay silt.
172
:Probably technically it's
called the silty loam.
173
:And so it really holds on to the
nutrients good, but it also has a pH
174
:that's really high, and so that tends
to cause problems for some species.
175
:Oh, and I have unlimited
irrigation water, basically.
176
:Ha, ha, ha, ha.
177
:Carmen: do you have a
hard freeze in the winter?
178
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, My
garden is covered with snow
179
:between November to mid March.
180
:And our low temperatures might be
around minus fifteen, minus twenty.
181
:And because we're in a valley, the cold
air will come and it will sit like for
182
:a week or something before the wind
blows and it warms up a little bit.
183
:Carmen: What are some of the crops
that you have found to be the
184
:most successful for land racing?
185
:Joseph Lofthouse: So, anything
that is promiscuously pollinating.
186
:So, that would be things like fava beans,
squash, melons, cucumbers, corn, any of
187
:the brassicas, like that would be cabbage
and mustards and, kale, things like that.
188
:Carmen: and promiscuously
189
:pollinating?
190
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes.
191
:So I use the term promiscuously
pollinating because there's a
192
:term in the seed industry that
is called open pollinated.
193
:And I want to distinguish what I'm
doing from open pollinated seeds.
194
:Because, what open pollinated actually,
or what we think it means is like, Oh,
195
:we don't really know who's the daddy.
196
:You know, there could be...
197
:but no, what it actually means is
we've done everything we know how
198
:to do with cages and isolation
distances to prevent the crops from
199
:actually crossing with each other.
200
:They might technically cross with each
other, but if a clone crosses with a
201
:clone, it's still a clone kind of idea.
202
:And so I use the term promiscuously
pollinating because it says we
203
:really do want to encourage that
things are cross pollinating.
204
:Carmen: Another term that you
mentioned is male sterility.
205
:Joseph Lofthouse: Eww, yeah.
206
:Carmen: How
207
:does that emerge?
208
:Joseph Lofthouse: Okay, so The seed
industry likes to sell hybrids because
209
:if they're selling a hybrid, then it's
basically proprietary, you need to
210
:buy the seed every year from them.
211
:And so with big fruited, or big seeded
things like squash that produce,
212
:you know, hundreds of seeds with one
attempt to the pollination, you can
213
:just do those pollinations by hand.
214
:But if you start dealing with little
things like carrots or cabbages that
215
:have these little teeny tiny flowers,
and they produce two or three or four
216
:seeds, it's really hard to make a hybrid.
217
:But, what the seed companies
discovered is they discovered if you
218
:took, like the nucleus out of a say
a cabbage and put it into a carrot
219
:that it wouldn't produce pollen.
220
:And so you have a plant
that is male sterile.
221
:And so then you can just grow a whole
bunch of seed and let the bees do
222
:the cross pollination because all of
the pollen will come from a different
223
:variety than the one that is sterile.
224
:And, So, a lot of the
cabbages and the carrots
225
:that
226
:Joseph Lofthouse: are sold as hybrids are
actually using that sort of technology.
227
:And I choose not to use that technology
in my garden because I like to know
228
:that my flowers are complete, that
they have the male part and the
229
:female part that's fully functional.
230
:Carmen: So if you see it
emerged, you just cull them?
231
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, so when I
originally started growing carrots, I
232
:just got carrots from the grocery store
and the seed catalog and, I planted
233
:hybrid carrots and it turned out that
about seventy percent of my seeds
234
:the next year had that sterile trait.
235
:And you can see that because the,
flowers were missing the anthers.
236
:And the anther is the part of the flower
that sheds pollen into the patch.
237
:And so it was really easy for
me just to pull those out.
238
:And if I miss a few, no big deal
because there's plenty of pollen
239
:running around the patch and
they'll get pollinated anyway.
240
:But it's just something that I watch
for and continuously remove as I see it.
241
:Carmen: So if that genetics is in the mix,
it will continue into further generations?
242
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes.
243
:And it's really complicated and biology
is fuzzy, but basically once that trait
244
:gets into a line, it doesn't come out.
245
:You can't get rid of it without, you
know, killing the plant kind of thing.
246
:Carmen: But it tends to
be on small flowered...
247
:Joseph Lofthouse: yes.
248
:There are no commercial bean hybrids,
I think, because you cross pollinate
249
:a bean and you get, you know,
three or four seeds kind of thing.
250
:Carmen: In your book you talk
about the processing of beans.
251
:Because I know some have problems
with beans, so do you mind just
252
:touching on that for a second?
253
:Because I found it really interesting.
254
:Joseph Lofthouse: So the way that I grow
beans is I plant them all, all many
255
:different varieties all jumbled up
together, and either the frost kills
256
:them or they just die in the fall.
257
:And I let them dry in the field, and
then I pull the whole plant, throw
258
:it on a tarp, jump up and down on it,
dance if I'm feeling fun and joyful,
259
:sing a song, and, and, and then You can
just scrape off the plant material and
260
:the beans are left laying on the tarp.
261
:And then you can dump them between
a couple of buckets while the wind is
262
:blowing and all of the chaffy stuff
will fly away, leaving you with beans.
263
:And then I need to sort them by
hand because sometimes I pull up a
264
:little piece of the root that has
little pebbles on it or something.
265
:And if I was being really careful, I
would cut the beans off at the root so
266
:that I wasn't taking that soil with me.
267
:And also if I'm being careful, I make
sure there's no pebbles in my shoes
268
:when I jump up and down on them.
269
:But usually what happens is I'm
harvesting the beans right before
270
:a terrible storm is expected.
271
:And So I'm rushed, and it's like,
just get it done, and we can sort
272
:them in the kitchen a month from
now when it's warm and toasty.
273
:Carmen: And you say that they have
poisons or they aren't very digestible.
274
:So, what do you do?
275
:Joseph Lofthouse: Beans have, I don't
know the name of the poison, but
276
:they have a little bit of poison in.
277
:And we have a long history as humans
of knowing how to deal with beans.
278
:You soak them.
279
:That takes some of the poisons out.
280
:You cook them for a long time at high
temperature, that takes the poisons out.
281
:But a lot of times, people that haven't
been trained in dealing with beans
282
:that way, and they'll just take, like
a bean and grind it up and make a
283
:flour out of it, and make a cookie,
and the cookie is barely cooked,
284
:and you bite into that cookie and
the poison just pours out at you.
285
:Maybe I'm a, what they call
a super taster, I don't know.
286
:But, but those kinds of things are
really annoying to me because we've
287
:known for thousands of years that
beans need to be cooked really well.
288
:Well, yeah, so corn really
should be nixtamalized.
289
:And that is cooking the
corn with an alkali.
290
:What they call it, calcium
oxide or calcium hydroxide.
291
:And what that does is it, eliminates a
lot of the toxins that come from mold.
292
:And it also greatly increases
the vitamin content of the corn.
293
:And so when corn got taken from the
native places where it was growing and
294
:it went to the rest of the world, it
caused diseases in people because they
295
:weren't treating it with the alkali first.
296
:And, let's see, pellagra, I think
is the name of the disease that,
297
:that came from replacing whatever
it was in their diet with corn
298
:that hadn't been cooked in alkali.
299
:And also another thing that cooking
in alkali does is it really enhances
300
:the flavor of the flour corns.
301
:Carmen: Do you find there are a lot of
different flavors between the colors?
302
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, there are.
303
:And some people like one
color better than another.
304
:And I tend to like a diversity
of colors, a diversity of flavors
305
:more than I like just the same
old boring flavor every time.
306
:Carmen: If you're doing a
patch of squash, are you going
307
:to keep the species separate?
308
:Joseph Lofthouse: No, I do not
keep species separate, and that is
309
:because the definition of a species
is two varieties or two plants
310
:that won't cross with each other.
311
:And biology is fuzzy, and so once
in a while there will be a cross,
312
:but I have only seen that, like,
one time in 15 years, between
313
:the normal squash varieties.
314
:There are two squash called the cushaws
and the moschatas, the butternuts and the
315
:cushaws, and I think of them as not quite
separate species, because I have from
316
:time to time seen a cross between those.
317
:But for the most part, I just don't
observe that in my day to day gardening.
318
:Carmen: So is there very
little separation in general?
319
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, because I am
trying to encourage cross pollination.
320
:And so, pollination is highly localized.
321
:And the best way to ensure cross
pollination is if two varieties
322
:are growing side by side.
323
:Because when a bee is visiting
flowers, it doesn't go from here, way
324
:over there, and then back to here.
325
:It goes from here, to the next closest
flower, to the next closest flower.
326
:So the closer we interplant things
that can cross pollinate, the more
327
:likely they are to actually cross.
328
:Carmen: So would that mean that
things that are self fertile you
329
:would plant very close together
to try and encourage crossing?
330
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, for example, beans
in my garden, they cross about 1 in 200.
331
:They can cross like 1 in 20, if
they're growing in an ecosystem,
332
:like by a swamp next to a forest
that has all kinds of pollinators
333
:that are coming into the garden.
334
:But out here in the desert , my
chances of cross pollination
335
:are much less on, beans.
336
:But my chances of cross
pollination, like on wheat, are
337
:higher because lower humidity
favors cross pollination on wheat.
338
:So, it's a mixed bag, but the
closer you plant things together,
339
:the more likely they are to cross.
340
:And, to go the other way about
it, if you want things not to
341
:cross, plant them further apart.
342
:For example, with my squash, I
tend to plant the orange squash
343
:on one end of the row and the green
squash on the other end of the row.
344
:So the oranges will mostly cross
pollinate with the oranges.
345
:The greens will mostly cross
pollinate with the greens.
346
:And then where they meet, I
end up with striped squash.
347
:And so, we can go both
ways with our pollination.
348
:Carmen: And what kind of traits
are you looking for in your squash?
349
:Joseph Lofthouse: So, the number one
trait that I always select for, well,
350
:there's two that I always select for.
351
:First is productivity.
352
:It has to produce fruit in my garden.
353
:And the second is flavor.
354
:It just has to taste
beautiful and delightful.
355
:I inadvertently selected for squash
that are easy to cut, because I
356
:was tasting every squash for years
before I saved seeds from it.
357
:And if it was hard to cut, I
was just composting it rather
358
:than saving seeds from it.
359
:And that was totally inadvertent.
360
:I didn't know I was doing it,
but when I realized it's like, oh
361
:yeah, you get what you select for.
362
:And then there are other traits show
up sometimes that might be interesting.
363
:For example, one time I found a squash
that had a fuzzy skin, and it's like,
364
:whoa, you know, what if the fuzz
kept a deer from eating it, or kept
365
:a rat from eating it, or what if the
fuzz, irritated the squash bugs?
366
:You know, and there's all kinds of
possibilities about things that you
367
:might see that might be useful later on.
368
:And I never did anything with that
squash, but it was interesting
369
:to think about the possibilities.
370
:Carmen: When you were starting
your, melon land race, did you
371
:have all different colors or were
they all orange cantaloupe type?
372
:Joseph Lofthouse: They were all
cantaloupe types that I started with.
373
:Some green fleshed ones came
into the population at one point,
374
:and later on I did a separate
population with green fleshed melons.
375
:So, there was just a lot to explore
there, and I didn't ever explore
376
:like the Armenian Cucumber types,
and I didn't explore the, what
377
:they call them, Casabas types.
378
:You know, so there would be a
lot that someone could do with
379
:melons that I haven't ever done.
380
:Carmen: What about the Solanaceae family?
381
:Have you done much
playing around with them?
382
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, so, the
most popular page on my website
383
:is actually about growing
potatoes from pollinated seeds.
384
:And that's been the most
popular page for like 15 years.
385
:And, What you can get is you can
just get a lot of beautiful varieties
386
:and colors and flavors that come
out of, out of those crosses.
387
:My favorite solanaceae, ooh, big word,
388
:is the tomatoes.
389
:And I was trying to breed with tomatoes
and I was just having a dickens of a time.
390
:And So I did a deep dive into the
genetics of tomatoes, and it turns out
391
:that 95 percent of the genetics got left
in the wild when they were domesticated,
392
:because a few tomato plants went from
the Andes Mountains up to Mexico, and
393
:then a few plants went from Mexico
to Europe, then they sent tomatoes
394
:from Europe to the rest of the world.
395
:And each time that the tomatoes
traveled, they didn't take
396
:their pollinators with them.
397
:And so that encouraged them
to become self pollinating.
398
:And they just shed all kinds of
genetic diversity that didn't
399
:get taken with them as well.
400
:And so, One day I was in my tomato
patch I was doing frost tolerance
401
:trials, planting 30 varieties and
seeing which ones did the best
402
:in the cold and with the frost.
403
:And there was one tomato plant, anytime
I went to my garden, there was a
404
:bumblebee on exactly that one plant.
405
:And it got me thinking we could turn
tomatoes into a cross pollinating species
406
:instead of a self pollinating species.
407
:And it turns out that in the
Andes, they grow primarily
408
:as cross pollinating species.
409
:Not only cross pollinating,
but 100 percent cross
410
:pollinating every single time.
411
:And so those tomatoes that do that
are green fruited, and the flavor
412
:is Not something you'd want to eat.
413
:But!
414
:So I crossed those tomatoes with domestic
tomatoes and, what I found was I found
415
:amazing flavors and amazing aromas.
416
:So, I thought I was going to do a project
to select for promiscuous flowers.
417
:And yes, that's one of the
primary goals of the project.
418
:But what I'm really chasing is fruits
that taste like guava, and, sea
419
:urchin, and melon, and citrus.
420
:Just these glorious, beautiful
flavors that make my heart sing.
421
:And, uh, ha, ha, ha.
422
:And, and so, the tomato project has
come to define my work as a farmer.
423
:'Cause I'm getting older, my ability
and my ambition are failing, but the
424
:Promiscuous Tomato Project just sings to
my heart and just brings me so much joy.
425
:And so that's the one I just hang
on to with everything I have.
426
:Carmen: What does the flower look like?
427
:Joseph Lofthouse: Oh, so in a domestic
tomato, the flowers are about half
428
:inch in diameter, just these little
things and they're pale colored.
429
:Some of the promiscuous tomato flowers
are like an inch and three quarters
430
:across, just these big flowers with
tremendous numbers of petals, and
431
:they're brightly colored, and they have
the style, which is the part that's
432
:receptive to pollen, is on the outside
of the flower, so it can attract, or
433
:it can rub against the belly of a bee.
434
:Oftentimes, a whole flower cluster
will open up one day, and there are
435
:these big fist sized flower clusters
that are way up above the foliage
436
:so the bees can really get to them.
437
:They're just joyful and beautiful, besides
having all these flavors and aromas
438
:that we'd never expect from a tomato.
439
:Carmen: What happens
in terms of the color?
440
:Joseph Lofthouse: So, I have been
selecting for orange colored tomatoes,
441
:because when I do blind taste testing
with people, they almost invariably
442
:prefer the flavors of the orange
tomatoes over any other color.
443
:I think the orange color in the tomatoes
is due to beta carotene, and beta carotene
444
:is converted to vitamin A in the body.
445
:And so I think people just
inherently, their bodies inherently
446
:know what's good for them.
447
:And one time when we were doing a
taste testing, I thought I'd be a
448
:smart aleck and I went and picked one
of the domestic tomatoes out of the
449
:field and brought it in and cut it.
450
:And after we tasted it, the guy
that was hosting us went to the
451
:kitchen and got a rag and came and
washed the cutting board so that it
452
:wouldn't contaminate the flavor of the
tomatoes we're going to taste next.
453
:Carmen: What happened for size?
454
:Joseph Lofthouse: I have been
selecting for tomatoes that are
455
:about the size of a ping pong ball.
456
:Call them saladettes or as
big as, four to six ounces.
457
:And that is partly due to my
ecosystem because I have about
458
:90 to 100 frost free days.
459
:And so I have to select for tomatoes
that jump out of the ground.
460
:They really grow fast and they ripen fast.
461
:And the smaller tomatoes tend to do that
quicker than the great big tomatoes.
462
:Someone in a warmer climate with longer
growing season could make other choices.
463
:Carmen: It's quite a short growing season.
464
:Joseph Lofthouse: Ha ha ha.
465
:So, if I buy tomatoes from a
seed catalog, 95 percent of them
466
:will fail for me because of the
shortness of the growing season.
467
:Basically, I can grow tomatoes that the
seed catalogs call maybe up to 70 days.
468
:But I'm better off with 55 or
60 day tomatoes, which leaves
469
:me hardly any to choose from.
470
:Carmen: In your initial planting
of squash, did you select
471
:ones that were short season?
472
:Joseph Lofthouse: What I find is
that the ecosystem does like 80
473
:percent of the selection for me.
474
:So the first year that I planted
butternut squash, I planted, oh, maybe 10
475
:varieties, and only, like, two or three
of them actually produced fruit for me.
476
:And my growing season
that year was 88 days.
477
:And then, I think two years later,
the growing season was 84 days long.
478
:And so the ecosystem selected heavy,
heavy, heavy for quick maturity.
479
:And what that does when I send my seeds to
someplace like, down south, my plants jump
480
:out of the ground, they grow like crazy,
they produce fruit, and then they die from
481
:the diseases and the pests and whatever.
482
:But they've already produced an
abundant harvest, so it doesn't matter.
483
:And then down south they
can plant a second crop.
484
:Carmen: Can you harvest the
seed from fruit that's not quite
485
:mature in your first season?
486
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, you can.
487
:Seeds tend to be viable a long time
before they're totally mature.
488
:And so you can harvest seeds from
very immature fruits, and they
489
:still often will produce seeds.
490
:And so, on my melons, that's what
happened the first year I planted them.
491
:I harvested only immature melons.
492
:But then, two years later, I
was harvesting melons weeks
493
:before my fall frosts.
494
:Carmen: So even though the parents
would have not made it through the
495
:growing season, just by growing
them there, the genetics adapted?
496
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, some of
the parents did make it through.
497
:And, like, 80 percent of the parents
didn't survive, didn't produce seeds.
498
:I can't really look at a seed catalog
and trust that, that it's going
499
:to actually apply to my garden.
500
:And so, I just end up randomly trying
varieties and what survives, shows that
501
:it was capable of surviving in my garden.
502
:And then, you mix up the genetics
of those, and you give them another
503
:chance, and some of them are
better, capable of surviving even
504
:better than their parents did.
505
:Carmen: And something else that you
mentioned is keeping the old seed and
506
:reintroducing it from previous seasons.
507
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, and the reason
I do that is because the climate
508
:here in the mountains is variable.
509
:Some years we'll have drought,
some years we'll have extra rainy,
510
:some years will be super hot,
some years will be kind of cool.
511
:And I save seeds from multiple years so
that I tend to get an average of what
512
:did good over all of those different
growing conditions, rather than having
513
:my whole population shift towards the
wet loving group or the dry loving group.
514
:Hedging my bets kind of deal.
515
:Carmen: So would that be
from like two years previous
516
:or what's the sort of process?
517
:Joseph Lofthouse: well for
me I keep a jar of seeds.
518
:Like 80 percent of that jar of
seeds will be new seeds and 20
519
:percent will be from previous years.
520
:But I don't, you know
I don't make a formula.
521
:I don't try to control that
and be in charge of it.
522
:I just make sure that there's some
older seed that's always hanging around.
523
:Carmen: Does your population or your
plantation have to be really large
524
:or can you scale a land race down?
525
:Joseph Lofthouse: You can scale
a landrace down because we're
526
:encouraging genetic diversity.
527
:And the reason to have large
populations is because the crops
528
:were so inbred that they were having
problems with being too inbred.
529
:And In one cob of my sweet corn, there's
more genetic diversity than, like, 10,
530
:000 acres worth of commercial sweet corn.
531
:And, ha ha ha, and, and so, small
scale, people can really grow landraces
532
:effectively, especially if you're sharing
seeds with your neighbors, if you're
533
:allowing promiscuous pollination, If
you bring in a new variety once in a
534
:while, then you can avoid those sort
of problems that inbreeding created
535
:in the open pollinated seed movement.
536
:Carmen: Touching back into
the Solanaceae for a second.
537
:Have you done any with
tomatillos or ground cherries?
538
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yes, I love
tomatillos because they have the
539
:100 percent outcrossing trait.
540
:And what that means is that when
somebody plants tomatillos in their
541
:garden, They become a weed in just a
year or two, and they never go away.
542
:You can't get rid of them.
543
:And I would love for tomatoes to end up
with that same sort of breeding system.
544
:And this last summer, I went on
a hike up in the mountains, and
545
:we have a local ground cherry.
546
:And I selected Well, not a bunch
of seeds, I worked really hard
547
:for a few little hints of a seed.
548
:But I'm growing those this
year and intending to introduce
549
:those into my garden as well.
550
:Carmen: I can't help but wonder
why there aren't more varieties
551
:or more projects developing them.
552
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well for me, I see
them everywhere because I wrote a
553
:book and a movement started about it.
554
:And so But, a bunch of my readers
got together and they made a non profit
555
:organization called Going to Seed.
556
:They came to my garden and made videos
about me talking about land race
557
:gardening and people donated enough
money to make those videos free.
558
:They made a, forum to talk about it.
559
:the Cliff Family Foundation donated
like 25, 000 so that we could support
560
:farmers in learning to grow this
way, and so about a dozen farmers are
561
:developing land races of various species.
562
:And so for me, I'm right in
the middle of everything, but
563
:Carmen: you said that's goingtoseed...
564
:Joseph Lofthouse: goingtoseed.org
565
:Carmen: org.
566
:I'll put that in the show notes.
567
:Joseph Lofthouse: Thank you.
568
:Carmen: Along with any other
links that you give me.
569
:You also mentioned potatoes.
570
:So, true seed potatoes.
571
:Joseph Lofthouse: So, so, the
favorite potato that I ever found by
572
:growing from seeds, the tubers were
about the size of a ping pong ball.
573
:But each plant would produce like
a gallon of these little tubers.
574
:And they were so beautiful to rinse
off and take to the farmer's market.
575
:Carmen: neat.
576
:What color were they?
577
:Joseph Lofthouse: They were a red
potato with a white inside, but some
578
:of the potatoes were just beautiful
like they'd be yellow inside with
579
:a blue skin, or they'd be a white
inside with red streaks through them.
580
:Just a whole bunch of diversity.
581
:Carmen: When you started with
the potatoes, did you have
582
:difficulty getting them to flower?
583
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, yes,
sorta, because potatoes are
584
:typically grown by cloning and
every time you clone something,
585
:it damages the DNA a little bit.
586
:And so most of the potatoes that people
grow are not capable of producing flowers.
587
:And so, we had to select for varieties
that were capable of producing flowers
588
:in the first place, and then once
those start crossing with each other,
589
:then they remember how to produce
flowers and they produce a lot of seed.
590
:But, those first years of finding
varieties that can produce
591
:seeds is kind of troubling.
592
:The same thing happens with
Like garlic and onions.
593
:If you've been growing a variety
that's a clone, it often
594
:has forgotten how to flower.
595
:But once they start crossing with each
other, then they remember how to flower.
596
:And they flower more reliably.
597
:And on onions, the reliable
flowering lasts for about 10 years.
598
:And then they start to
forget how to flower again.
599
:Carmen: That's pretty interesting.
600
:What about spinach?
601
:Joseph Lofthouse: Oh, spinach is nice
because it has male plants and female
602
:plants, and so you could create your own
hybrids if you had two varieties and you
603
:wanted to cross them with each other.
604
:It'd just be a matter of watching
early in the season and chopping
605
:out the female plants in one row and
the male plants in the other row.
606
:Spinach is, for me, is one of those
crops where you plant ten varieties
607
:and half of them are just going
to fail totally, and half of them
608
:are going to be beautiful plants.
609
:Carmen: How do you deal with things
like carrots and beets being biennial?
610
:Joseph Lofthouse: It's hard, because
I live in a super cold climate, and so
611
:I can't really leave them out in the
elements, and so I have to either mulch
612
:them really heavily so that maybe they
survive and maybe they rot because of the
613
:mulch, or I bring them inside and try to
keep them alive in a refrigerator, but
614
:that takes up my space, or, you know,
in a garage, but that's kind of iffy,
615
:and so the biennials are rough on me.
616
:It would be nice if I could
select for varieties that
617
:could handle the outside cold.
618
:I have done that on a few things,
like I developed a variety of
619
:kale that can survive my winters.
620
:Then that makes the biennials
easier to deal with.
621
:Carmen: In terms of pests,
you mentioned brassica family.
622
:ha.
623
:Is it just selecting for what can survive?
624
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, and I don't do
any kind of spraying or poisoning or
625
:killing of the pests, because I consider
them to be blessings to my garden.
626
:They're teaching my plants how
to be strong, how to survive, how
627
:to collaborate with each other.
628
:And so I hardly even know that I have
a pest in my garden or a disease.
629
:I remember one time a lady asked if
she could grow a little garden in my
630
:field, and I'm like, sure, go ahead.
631
:So she bought some squash from the
seed company and she planted it and
632
:the squash bugs just pounced on it and
all kinds of diseases started affecting
633
:the foliage and it was just terrible.
634
:And.
635
:I know they say you're not supposed to
laugh at other people's misery, but I
636
:was so happy and joyful that her plants
just died like that because it, it
637
:showed me that those pests and diseases
are in my garden, but they've learned
638
:to live in harmony with the plants.
639
:And so it was just a,
beautiful experience for me.
640
:And I'm sorry for the
plant's misery, but laughs
641
:Carmen: Even things like the
caterpillars on the brassicas?
642
:Joseph Lofthouse: I don't really
notice much of a problem with them.
643
:I know that if I grow red brassicas,
that they're more resistant to the
644
:caterpillars because the the predator
can see the green caterpillars on the
645
:red cabbage, and it's less of a problem.
646
:Carmen: Would you also be looking for
less wrinkly kale, that sort of thing?
647
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah, well, for
example, on spinach one time I, I
648
:took a puckery leaf spinach to my
sister and she cooked it and it was
649
:totally filled with little wireworms.
650
:And I was so horrified and so I
started selecting for spinach that had
651
:perfectly smooth leaves so that there
would be no place for the bugs to hide.
652
:I imagine that similar types of
strategies can be used with the
653
:brassicas and the cabbage moths.
654
:Carmen: How do these plants
adjust to your style of gardening?
655
:What traits have you noticed that emerge
that really show your style of gardening?
656
:Joseph Lofthouse: Well, I can
think of a tomato as an example.
657
:Because I grow tomatoes
sprawling on the ground.
658
:And they're just in the dirt.
659
:I don't try to protect them or trellis
them or not even really weed them.
660
:And so a neighbor asked me how I could
grow tomatoes that are so clean and,
661
:and I'm like, that's just how they grow.
662
:But then I started paying attention, and
I had been saving tomato seeds only from
663
:the tomatoes that were beautiful tomatoes.
664
:I wasn't saving seeds from those that
had got in the dirt and rotted, and turns
665
:out that the tomato vines had developed
an arching architecture to their vines.
666
:So the vine would go up and make a
little bridge kind of thing that the
667
:fruits could hang up off the ground.
668
:And then that kept them clean
and it kept them from rotting.
669
:And I didn't intend to do that.
670
:It's just one of those things that
they adapted to my way of doing things.
671
:And I find that over and over again,
the plants are figuring out my way of
672
:doing things and adapting to it even
if I'm not consciously aware of what
673
:I'm doing or what they're adapting to.
674
:For example, on my beans, because I do the
stomping harvest, pretty much, any bean
675
:that is like green when I do that stomp
, I'm not going to save seeds from it.
676
:And so I've inadvertently selected
for seeds or for beans that I can
677
:harvest all on one day, they're ready
before my fall frost or right with it.
678
:So I inadvertently selected for
uniformity of harvest time for example.
679
:Where somebody that was growing a
pole bean and they were harvesting
680
:one pod at a time, they would be
selecting for a longer harvest window.
681
:Carmen: And if you come across a
particular fruit, whether it be a
682
:melon or a squash, and it's just, or
a tomato, and it's just so delicious.
683
:Do you isolate it or do you
continue it in the landrace?
684
:Joseph Lofthouse: So typically what
I'll do is I'll save seeds from that
685
:separately, and I'll plant more of
that next year, or I'll plant it in
686
:a corner of the garden so I can see
how it's going to perform, if the
687
:beautiful flavor is still there.
688
:And if I like that a lot, then I might
save more seeds from that next year and
689
:less from the ones I don't like as much.
690
:So, yeah, I'm constantly paying
attention to what I love and
691
:encouraging more of that.
692
:Carmen: You mention in your
book, singing to your plants.
693
:Joseph Lofthouse: Uh huh.
694
:Carmen: Would you mind,
perhaps sharing a song?
695
:Joseph Lofthouse: I would love to.
696
:So I'm going to switch my microphone.
697
:I often sing this song to my plants
in my garden, and it reminds me
698
:that I am part of the ecosystem,
and the ecosystem is part of me.
699
:And it goes like this.
700
:May all beings, everywhere,
all be happy and free.
701
:In Sanskrit, the words are
Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu
702
:May all beings everywhere
all be happy and free.
703
:May all beings everywhere
all be happy and free.
704
:May all beings everywhere
all be happy and free.
705
:Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu
706
:Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu
707
:Lokah Samastah Sukinho Bhavantu
708
:May all beings everywhere
all be happy and free.
709
:May all beings everywhere
all be happy and free.
710
:Carmen: Thank you.
711
:Joseph Lofthouse: Thank you, Carmen.
712
:Carmen: So I've mentioned
your book a number of times.
713
:Joseph Lofthouse: Mm-Hmm.
714
:Carmen: Would you mind letting
people know where they can find it?
715
:How they can find you?
716
:Joseph Lofthouse: So, I spend
most of my online time talking
717
:about adaptation gardening, land
race gardening, at goingtoseed.
718
:org.
719
:My book is available wherever books
are sold, including, like, Amazon,
720
:and Barnes Noble, and Target.
721
:Landrace race Gardening, Food
security through biodiversity
722
:and promiscuous pollination.
723
:It could also be subtitled like
how to grow food without buying
724
:seeds, fertilizers, or poisons.
725
:Carmen: when you're talking about tasting
everything and how you can taste poisons.
726
:Plants do produce these poisons, but
you taste every plant or every fruit
727
:that you're going to save seed from.
728
:Joseph Lofthouse: I made myself so
sick one day by tasting lettuce.
729
:Carmen: So thank you very, very much for,
730
:for joining me.
731
:Actually, I do have one other
little question about the squash.
732
:So I do have a hybrid that
has naturally emerged.
733
:I have a tendency to let things self seed
and when they come up I let them grow.
734
:And I had a hybrid that came up in a
year that my squash were absolutely
735
:decimated by the squash vine borer.
736
:And it came up on the compost pile
and it looks like it's a cross
737
:between moschata and probably maxima.
738
:Joseph Lofthouse: Okay.
739
:Carmen: And the vines were hard, but the
fruit looked a lot more like a maxima.
740
:And the flesh was absolutely
delicious, and it produced so many
741
:fruit when all of the others died.
742
:But there were barely
any seeds in the fruit.
743
:So I saved them all, and I've
been planting them out for the
744
:next two years, but I haven't
gotten that trait to come back.
745
:Joseph Lofthouse: yeah, so, interspecies
hybrids are often not very fertile.
746
:I've seen that a few times when
I've tried making those crosses.
747
:If you ever find an offspring that has
that little thin vine that will resist
748
:the borers, and it has the beautiful
flavor of the maxima, then woo hoo!
749
:Right.
750
:Carmen: If you can get it to come
back in the future generations,
751
:that was the problem that I had.
752
:I keep trying.
753
:Joseph Lofthouse: Offspring tend
to resemble their parents and
754
:their grandparents, but sometimes
the trait skips a generation.
755
:Carmen: So I just have to keep trying
756
:Joseph Lofthouse: Yeah.
757
:There is a squash that's an interspecies
hybrid called Tetsuka Buto, which is
758
:sold by Pine Tree Garden Seeds, and
that is halfway in between a moschata
759
:and a maxima already, and So that
might be a place for you to look.
760
:Carmen: To bring that one into my race.
761
:Joseph Lofthouse: huh.
762
:Carmen: Well, thanks again.
763
:I really appreciated the conversation.
764
:It's been lovely.
765
:Joseph Lofthouse: Thank you, Carmen.
766
:Carmen: Thanks for listening.
767
:If there's anyone that you would like to
hear included in the Solanaceae series,
768
:please don't hesitate to let me know.
769
:I always love hearing your thoughts,
comments, and inspirations.
770
:Just head over to CarmenPorter.
771
:com to connect.
772
:Happy garden dreaming.